July 25, 2010

Chapter 13 Bankruptcy - What has to be paid?

When a chapter 13 case is filed, a "plan" must be proposed that tells the court and creditors how each debt is going to be treated i.e. paid or not, how much and when.

How each type of debt is treated, depends on the bankruptcy code and case law. Generally, a chapter 13 filer must have enough income to pay the following in full:

1. Living Expenses

The law assumes that you need a certain amount of money to pay for your "reasonable" living expenses. What is considered to be reasonable is litigated around the country each week. In Arizona, your reasonable living expenses typically includes: mortgage, food, utilities, insurances, out of pocket medical care costs, upkeep on home, hoa dues, property tax, child care, spousal maintenance, daycare, costs related to maintaining your small business, or related to your employment, gas and upkeep on car, laundry, mandatory withholdings at work, car lease and a few other items. These items are paid outside the plan of course.

2. Car Loan

Car payments are paid through the chapter 13 plan as part of the plan payment. The plan will often change the treatment of the car loan creditor. The law often allows for the debtor to pay less in principal and or interest and the length of the loan payout is either shortened or lengthened.

3. "Priority" Debt

Certain taxes, child support, spousal maintenance are the most common debts that must be paid in full through the plan.

4. Tax Lien

If a taxing entity has properly recorded a tax lien and the debtor has assets with value, the tax lien will have to be paid through the plan with interest.

5. Mortgage Arrears

If behind on a home loan, the amount that is owed will be paid as part of the plan payment and any foreclosure will be stopped while the payments are made.

6. Value of Non Exempt Assets

If the debtor has a asset that is not considered "protected" under state law, in order to create a viable chapter 13 plan, unsecured creditors must be paid it's value during the plan. If the debtor has an antique jukebox worth 10000.00, these creditors will need to be paid 10000.00 during the plan or give the jukebox up to the chapter 13 trustee for sale and distribution as in a chapter 7 bankruptcy.

Continue reading "Chapter 13 Bankruptcy - What has to be paid?" »

Bookmark and Share

September 21, 2009

Ride Thru, Reaffirmation Agreements and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, has decided the issue of whether a reaffirmation agreement is necessary in bankruptcy in relation to personal property.

Prior to the 2005 changes to the bankruptcy code that resulted in what is now known as "bapcpa", a debtor could "retain and pay" or "ride through" on it's car loan as long as he stayed current on the car payment.

The creditor with the security interest in the car was left without any legal obligation to sue on, should the car be surrendered or repossessed and a deficiency balance existed.

No reaffirmation agreement was typically necessary. (read more about what a reaffirmation agreement is here)

Not signing a reaffirmation agreement was good for the debtor because he obtained the best of both worlds as a result. i.e. Keep the car and make the payment, but not be liable on any deficiency balance should he not be able to afford the car down the road and after surrender.

Many attorneys felt as a result, that advising a client to sign a reaffirmation agreement with the creditor on the car loan inside of the bankruptcy case was malpractice. Especially if the car was upside down, i.e. it was worth much less then what was owed on it.

If the reaffirmation was signed unnecessarily and the debtor lost the car down the road he would then owe what sometimes amounted to a large deficiency balance nullifying some of the "fresh start" benefit gained in the bankruptcy case.

Continue reading "Ride Thru, Reaffirmation Agreements and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals" »

Bookmark and Share